Home
About IME
Site Map
Clinic Locations
F.A.Q.
Mission Statement
Quality Assurance
Medical Legal Services
Service Order Form
Physicians
Physician 
Intake Form
Legal Nurse Consultants
IME Connections
Medical
Legal
Legal Nurse Consultant

 

 

 

IME,Inc.
211 Beaumont
Traverse City, 
Michigan MI 49684

Tel: (800)
968-4637

info@imei.com

 

 

 

(800) 968-4637 

Independent Medical Evaluations, Inc.

A National Company Providing
Comprehensive IME Medical Legal
Services In All 50 States


 info@imei.com


Tear, Meniscus of the Knee, Medial and/or Lateral

I.   Background

Tears of the menisci of the knee are common and occur in three categories of patients: 1) the athletic teenager or young adult who sustains trauma to the knee with immediate symptoms; 2) the middle-aged patient whose injury to the knee usually involves weightbearing and twisting motion, and 3) the patient who has no recognized injury to the knee or who injures a degenerative knee meniscus after minimal trauma. The presenting complaints are usually pain over the joint line and a "catching" sensation. The patient may also describe a "giving way" sensation or locking or blocking of knee motion. The physician may note mild to moder­ate knee joint swelling.

II. Diagnostic Criteria

A. Pertinent historical and physical findings

The patient usually gives a history of knee injury, often associat­ed with a rotational component. The patient may note an inabili­ty to extend the knee fully or a blocking sensation to knee motion. Physical findings include joint effusion, joint line ten­derness, and pain on rotational stress to the knee frequently re­ferred to the joint line area. Mild thigh muscle atrophy may be present. McMurray's or varus loading test may be positive.

B. Appropriate diagnostic tests and examinations (one or more of the following may be indicated to establish the diagnosis)

1.   AP and lateral radiographs, preferably with the patient standing. Additional views may be indicated (e.g. 30-degree flexed knee views; lateral, tunnel and patellar axial radiographs)

2.   Arthrocentesis with synovial fluid analysis if indicated

3.   Arthrogram

4.   MRI

5.   Arthroscopy (diagnostic)

6.   Bone scan if osteonecrosis is suspected

7.   Blood serum analysis if indicated

C. Supporting evidence

Diagnostic arthroscopy is effective in identifying most meniscus tears. In older patients in whom degenerative tears are common, bone scan and other diagnostic tests may be necessary to verify that the symptoms are not caused by other problems such as os­teonecrosis, crystalline-induced synovitis or tumor.

A. Outpatient treatment

1. Nonoperative treatment

a. Indications

1)     Patients with mild knee symptoms and no functional disability

2)     Patients in whom medical contraindications to surgical treatment exist

b. Treatment options

1)     Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs

2)     Arthrocentesis

3)     Short-term immobilization and/or limited weightbearing

c. Home health care may be self-administered

d. Rehabilitation

1)     Range of motion and strengthening exercises

2)     Protected weightbearing

e. Supporting evidence

Tears of the meniscus may be associated with only mild and nondisabling symptoms. Degenerative tears in older patients are often not disabling.

2. Ambulatory surgery

a. Indications

Symptomatic tear of the meniscus in a healthy patient

b. Treatment options

1)  Arthroscopic meniscectomy

2)  Arthroscopic meniscus repair, open, closed, or combined

3)  Arthrotomy, when arthroscopic techniques not feasible

c. Home health care

d. Rehabilitation

1)  Strengthening and range of motion exercises

2)  Progressive weightbearing

e. Supporting evidence

Arthroscopic meniscectomy in the ambulatory setting is an acceptable procedure in the healthy patient and has been shown not to be associated with an increased morbidity.

B. Inpatient treatment

1.      Nonoperative treatment: not indicated

2.      Operative treatment

a. Indications for admission

1)  Patients whose associated medical conditions contraindicate knee surgery in an ambulatory setting

2)  Associated injury (e.g. ligament injury, tibial plateau fracture)

b. Treatment options

1)  Arthroscopic meniscectomy

2)  Arthroscopic meniscus repair, open, closed, or combined

3) Arthrotomy

c. Indications for discharge

1)     Uncomplicated cases may be discharged as soon as the patient is ambulatory, in some cases with protected weightberring.

2)     Complicated - The hospital stay may be prolonged

a)      If knee joint drain required postoperatively

b)     If severe postoperative pain requires medica­tion, intramuscularly

c)      If wound complications occur

d)     If medical complications arise

e)      If more extensive surgery is necessary

   d. Home health care may be needed for

1)  Medically ill patients with wound problems

2)  Older patients whose recovery is compromised

   e. Rehabilitation

1)  Strengthening and range of motion knee exercises

2)  Progressive weightbearing

   f. Supporting evidence

Surgery in an ambulatory setting poses some risk to medically unstable patients, so inpatient management is indicated for them. Admission is also indicated if there is an increased chance for wound complications, as in a patient with associated diabetes mellitus, or for a patient who needs consid­erable assistance in rehabilitation.

C. Estimated duration of care

1.      Depends on age of patient, amount of pathologic change found in the knee, and treatment of the torn meniscus (repair or removal)

2.      Generally extends for about six months

D. Anticipated outcomes

a.   Improved knee joint function with few or no residual symptoms

b.  Possible predisposition to the development of degenerative joint disease.

c.    Outcome may be influenced by the type of tear, the severity of tear, the type of procedure and the general integrity of the joint.

E. Evolving therapeutic procedures 1. Meniscal transplantation

F. Modifiers (age, sex, and co-morbidity)

Meniscal tears occur in a broad range of patients, who exhibit a variety of pathologic changes. The mechanisms of injury in­clude acute trauma, or minimal trauma in patients with degen­erative changes. These changes may themselves cause the tear without attendant injury. A single identifiable course of patient management is difficult to determine because of the variability of symptoms presented by this differing population. There are no conclusive scientific studies available to confirm these clinical impressions.

 

 

 



Independent Medical Evaluations, Inc. Corporate Office
IME, Inc.
211 Beaumont Place
Traverse City, Michigan-MI, USA 49684
Phone: (231) 929-1474
Toll-Free: (800) 968-4637
Fax: (231) 929-4356
Email: info@imei.com



IME, Inc. Home | Legal Nurse Consultants
Medical Legal Services | Board Certified Physicians
Medical Records - Legal Services FAQ | Physician Intake Form
Service Order Form | Legal Nurse Consulting Info
Independent Medical Evaluation Site Map

(800) 968-4637